History as Science or Literature: Explaining Canadian Confederation, 1858-1867
"History as Science or Literature: Explaining Canadian Confederation 1858-1867" was delivered as a public lecture at the Canadian High Commission in London in 1989. As the title indicates, it had a dual aim – first, to discuss the methodology used by historians in their attempts to explain past events and, second and more specifically, to examine how these approaches had been employed to account for the apparently sudden movement to unite the provinces of British North America that began in 1864 and culminated in the establishment of the Dominion of Canada three years later.
Context These enquiries were sharpened by two developments in my own career. In the early nineteen-eighties, my interests broadened out from the safe pastures of History and I became active in the cross-disciplinary field of Canadian Studies. I was immediately stimulated by the lively fellowship of the British Association for Canadian Studies but I confess that I was wary about the need to sit through presentations in alien disciplines. Some of these, I fear, I probably secretly regarded as inferior to the my own subject, which I took for granted was located at the focal point of all intellectual activity. In fact, listening to David Ingram discussing issues in Canadian urban geography or Cedric May gently interweaving themes in Quebec literature proved to be not only very interesting but also challenging methodological revelations. Colleagues working in other fields did not merely explain what they were doing, they also made clear how they went about their business. In my experience, when historians talked to each other in lectures and seminars, they generally plunged straight into some episode or issue from long ago, seemingly taking for granted that we were all agreed on the rules of the game. This was not always so. I began to attempt to ask myself what I could specifically and distinctively contribute to Canadian Studies as a historian: simply telling stories was not enough. The problem of definition was further complicated by the fact that History was located in a vague frontier zone that straddled the Humanities, with their emphasis upon creativity, and the Social Sciences, which were relentlessly analytical.
This questioning of the role of History when exposed to a broader academic discourse develop in parallel with a more specific interpretive shift in my assessment of my own research. My PhD thesis had examined British policy towards British North America in the mid-nineteenth century. In particular, I had examined the way in which the political and journalistic elite had come to favour the eventual union of the provinces as the best way of creating a bulwark against the expansion of the United States. Although British attitudes were relatively superficial – for instance, few British statesmen had much grasp of Canadian realities, such as internal distance – the metropolitan consensus in favour of a colonial union took shape before the idea struck any deep root in the provinces themselves.
Working, as it were, on the margins of Canadian history, I had gratefully accepted the portrayal of the movement for Confederation as outlined by an impressive generation of English-Canadian scholars, a picture that constituted a very satisfactory and essentially interlocking explanation. A set of circumstances and challenges arose in 1864 that made Confederation the necessary and – above all – the right answer for the provinces, one that inevitably predicated the creation of a second transcontinental nation in North America. As a student and later as a teacher, I had eagerly embraced this package, but gradually its very neatness began to make me question it. The individual threads did not always point towards a single answer so imperatively as they were portrayed. Nor did the elements necessary combine in the way that they were so patriotically presented. In addition, I became uneasy that the proclamation of the inevitability of Confederation involved the attribution of stupidity or perversity to its critics, many of whom advanced cogent arguments against the project and even predicted some of the problems that would later emerge.
In seeking alternative ways of accounting for the establishment of the Dominion of Canada in 1867, I went back to the textbooks to look more closely at the arguments advanced by that great pioneering cohort of Canadian historians. I was intrigued to discover that some of them had appealed to analogies drawn from physics or mathematics. In some cases, a half-attempt had been made to shoehorn the pattern of events into some scientific law, an initiative usually abandoned after tantalising the reader with the author's profundity of understanding. Other examples were simply literary borrowings of scientific imagery, which brought my enquiry back to Square One. An invitation to contribute to the Canada House Lecture Series provided an opportunity to explore issues related to the defintion of History and the applicability of its methodology to the problem of explaining Canadian Confederation.
The lecture (number 41 in a wide-ranging series) was delivered at Canada House in Trafalgar Square on 8 February 1989. One-off lectures and occasional papers were a common form of academic publication at the time, but their preservation has proved a challenge to librarians and the fact that few are now extant offers some justification for the resurrection of the text. Perhaps the themes may be of interest to professional colleagues who also ruminate on the nature of our field of study. From long and resigned experience, I am aware that few jobbing historians have much knowledge of the Canadian past, but I hope there is enough information embedded in the text to illuminate the arguments advanced.
Reviving the text also gives me a welcome opportunity to pay tribute to Michael J. Hellyer, Academic Relations Officer at Canada House. An Englishman with an informed enthusiasm for Canada and tireless in his commitment to his mission, Michael Hellyer gave unobstrusive but vital support to the Canadian Studies community in Britain. The handsome production of this published lecture – irrespective of its content – is one of many testimonies to his achievement.
ENDNOTES begin at page 29
































Afterword There is little point in fine-tuning the text of a lecture delivered 37 years ago, the more so as I stand by its general arguments. Some of my claims may perhaps be suspected as debating points. For instance, it was objected that my reference to Canada having six prime ministers in the five years between 1891 and 1896 in no way indicated instability in the political system. Rather, the frequent changes largely reflected the difficulty the Conservatives had in finding a successor to Sir John A. Macdonald, while it is only fair to note that two of the vacancies were caused by death in office. The scientist alluded to on page 2 who discovered a wonder drug but could not explain how it worked was of course Sir Alexander Fleming: the fact that it was left to other researchers to solve the miracle of penicillin in no way detracted from Fleming's achievement. It is also pleasant to note that G.M. Trevelyan, whose distaste for Canada opens the lecture, was considered as a possible Governor-General in 1945 (he would have been the last British appointee). Trevelyan made it to a short-list of three before withdrawing his name. (D. Cannadine, G.M. Trevelyan: a Life in History [1992], 18.)
Subsequently, I developed the argument of the lecture relating to the causes of Confederation in chapter 2 of Britain and the Origins of Canadian Confederation, 1837-1867 (Vancouver, 1995). An invitation to deliver the Joanne Goodman Lectures at the University of Western Ontario in 1996 gave me a further opportunity and incentive to discuss historical methodology. The themes first explored in the Canada House lecture were expanded in Past Futures: the Impossible Necessity of History (Toronto, 2004).